Case Results

When the manufacturer won't make it right, we're ready to take it to a jury.

Selected California lemon law results. Each depended on the facts of that case, and results will differ on different facts.

Ford Jury trial · 2010 Ford F-350 diesel

$383,000

Jack Ferra, a carpenter, relied on his F-350 for work. After years of repairs, the engine failed twice. Ford would not offer more than $20,000, so PLC took the case to trial. The jury found for Jack, and with the civil penalty, attorney fees and costs, the total judgment came to $383,000.

  • Severe engine noise and excess exhaust smoke
  • Turbocharger failure and an unresolved check-engine light
  • Sudden loss of power
  • Radiator leaks, water pump replacements and continuous oil leaks
  • The engine failed twice

This result depended on the facts of this case. The total includes the civil penalty, attorney fees and costs awarded.

Jury verdicts  ·  Buybacks  ·  Settlements  ·  Cash and keep

Selected results, by vehicle

Mercedes-BenzLease settlement

$147,000

2022 Mercedes-Benz EQS

No-starts · software faults · proximity sensors

CadillacSettlement

$109,000

2023 Cadillac CT5

Engine misfires · starting · steering pull

JeepBuyback

$94,000

2022 Jeep Grand Cherokee 4xe

Engine failure · unintended acceleration · suspension

ChevroletSettlement

$89,000

2021 Chevrolet Suburban

Coolant leaks · turbocharger · steering

ChevroletSettlement

$82,000

2024 Chevrolet Traverse

Brake noise · brake slipping

PorscheCash and keep

$21,500

2021 Porsche Taycan

Electronic glitches · software modules

Each result depended on the facts of that case.

The full stories

2010 Ford F-350: $383,000 total judgment after a jury trial

Jack Ferra is a carpenter, and his 2010 Ford F-350 diesel was the truck his business ran on. Over several years it had severe engine noise, turbocharger failure, an unresolved check-engine light, excess exhaust smoke, sudden power loss, leaking radiators, water pump replacements and continuous oil leaks, and the engine failed twice.

Ford would not offer more than $20,000. PLC took the case to trial. The jury found in Jack's favor, and with the civil penalty, attorney fees and costs, the total judgment came to $383,000.

This result depended on the facts of this case. The total includes the civil penalty, attorney fees and costs awarded.

2022 Mercedes-Benz EQS (lease): $147,000

Our client leased a new EQS and soon had repeated no-start conditions, software faults that affected how the car drove, and defective front and rear proximity sensors. Several dealership repair attempts did not fix the problems. PLC pursued the manufacturer and obtained a $147,000 recovery.

This result depended on the facts of this case.

2023 Cadillac CT5: $109,000

The new CT5 had recurring engine misfires, starting problems and electronic faults, a steering pull and a noisy HVAC system. After several unsuccessful repair attempts, our client came to PLC, and we obtained a total recovery of $109,000.

This result depended on the facts of this case.

2022 Jeep Grand Cherokee 4xe: $94,000 buyback

Our client reported suspension shudder and vibration, episodes of unintended acceleration, transmission faults, repeated suspension problems, starting difficulties and, eventually, engine failure. PLC pursued the claim and the manufacturer agreed to repurchase the vehicle, for a $94,000 recovery.

This result depended on the facts of this case.

2021 Chevrolet Suburban: $89,000

Over months of driving, the Suburban had persistent coolant leaks, turbocharger repair attempts, steering defects and HVAC failures. PLC built a lemon law case showing the defects substantially impaired the vehicle, and obtained an $89,000 recovery for our clients.

This result depended on the facts of this case.

2024 Chevrolet Traverse: $82,000

Soon after purchase, the new Traverse had constant brake noise and brake slipping. The brake pads were replaced twice, but the dealership could not fix the underlying problem. PLC took legal action and obtained an $82,000 recovery from the manufacturer.

This result depended on the facts of this case.

2021 Porsche Taycan: $21,500 cash and keep

Our client had recurring electronic faults and software module defects, along with out-of-pocket costs, but wanted to keep the car. PLC negotiated a $21,500 cash-and-keep settlement: our client was compensated and kept the Porsche, with its remaining warranty coverage.

This result depended on the facts of this case.

“The settlement I received was much more than I ever expected, and went a long way in my purchase of a new vehicle.”

John Burke
2021 Chevrolet Tahoe
Read client reviews →

Statement from an actual client. A testimonial is not a promise or prediction about the outcome of your matter.

Is your car the next case?

Start My Free Case Review

Attorney Advertising. These are selected, representative results, not a complete record of the firm's cases. Each result depended on the facts of that case, and results will differ on different facts. Prior results do not predict or indicate a similar outcome in any future matter. Logos identify vehicle makes only; Premier Legal Center is not affiliated with, or endorsed by, any vehicle manufacturer. Premier Legal Center, APC, La Jolla, California.

(619) 235-3200 Free Case Review